South African society is grappling with complex issues surrounding masculinity, mental health, and violence. This article delves into the influences of South African male culture, exploring how societal expectations, traditional norms, and historical factors impact the well-being of men and contribute to alarming rates of violence, particularly against women. It examines how the pressure to conform to rigid masculine ideals can lead to internal conflict, psychological strain, and mental health difficulties.
The Contradictions of Masculinity in South Africa
Masculinity and masculine culture are shaped by societal norms and expectations, which typically emphasize strength, stoicism, and dominance. In the South African context, masculinity is closely intertwined with patriarchy, as many indigenous groups remain hierarchically structured, with men positioned at the top.
"Hegemonic masculinity", a concept defined by Connell and Messerschmidt, refers to culturally endorsed norms that reinforce male power and subjugate women. Adherence to these traditional ideals can result in internal conflict, leading to stress, psychological strain and gender role conflict as men attempt to conform to rigid expectations. Research also highlights the diverse nature of masculinities, and the contradictory pressures men face in their personal and social contexts.
South African men think women should be under their control. There is an idea that violence is justifiable as a means to keep women in their place. This has not changed in 20 years and even though the South African murder rate has dropped by 50% since 1999, rape figures have not.
Experts say South African society features all the known causes of rape and violence, including a historical culture of "might is right", a wealth gap that makes men feel weak, an unequal relationship between women and men, lack of adequate childcare, which results in the neglect of boys, and high male unemployment.
Read also: Property Practitioners Regulatory Authority
Traditional Values and Expectations
In alignment with traditional values, masculinity in South Africa is frequently linked to heterosexuality and procreation. Men are often expected to fulfil roles as protectors and providers, with fatherhood serving as a critical marker of identity and social status. For many men, fatherhood is not merely a personal achievement but a societal expectation that reinforces their position within their families and communities. These cultural norms create considerable pressure to conform to traditional gender roles, with fatherhood and marriage viewed as essential to achieving recognition, respect and identity.
The Northern Sotho people, commonly known as the Bapedipeople, are one of the indigenous groups found largely in northern South Africa, notably in the Limpopo province. Cultural traditions, social institutions and historical practices all influence the social organisation of the family among the Northern Sotho people. Traditionally, males were responsible for tasks such as hunting, herding and protection, while women were frequently in charge of home administration, childcare and agricultural pursuits. This was and continues to be reinforced by the patriarchal social system, which is a frequent characteristic in Northern Sotho households since the father or eldest male is often viewed as the head of the home. The father has the power to oversee family-related choices and/or decisions.
The Limpopo province (one of the provinces in South Africa), where most northern territories are situated, is one of South Africa’s poorest provinces, and while unemployment is a concern throughout South Africa, it is especially prevalent in the Limpopo province. As a result, a study revealed that loss of hope in the province due to unemployment and socioeconomic constraints, which were worsened by the coronavirus disease (COVID-19), among males who conform to the masculine ideology led to psychological distress, as they felt that they were not “man enough” since they could no longer provide for their families - a role that is considered the responsibility of men in the Northern Sotho culture.
The Dark Side of Masculinity: Violence Against Women
The profoundly macho culture spans racial groups and provides some explanation for the country's shocking rates of domestic violence. Police statistics on domestic violence are limited. But 15,609 murders and 64,500 reported rapes in 2011-12 suggest massive levels of violence in South African homes. Household surveys have found that 40% of men have hit their partner and one in four men have raped a woman. Three-quarters of men who admit to having raped women say they did so first as teenagers. While a quarter of women had been raped, just 2% of those raped by a partner reported the incident to police.
South African men think women should be under their control. There is an idea that violence is justifiable as a means to keep women in their place. This has not changed in 20 years and even though the South African murder rate has dropped by 50% since 1999, rape figures have not.
Read also: Discover Thula Thula
While the country has a Domestic Violence Act that enables police to intervene if a woman fears attack, it is poorly implemented. Too often the women who come to us have been told by the police, 'He seems like a nice guy, surely you can sort it out'. Other women are turned away from courts because there is a shortage of magistrates.
The media raise the issue with regularity. Column inches were occupied last month with wonderment at the outpouring of grief in India over the rape of a New Delhi student on a bus. Commentators asked why such a reaction in South Africa, where gang rapes are a daily occurrence, is unthinkable. Black Friday, during which radio chat show hosts called on listeners to wear black, was a media attempt to create a reaction. But South Africa appeared largely unmoved.
Mental Health Challenges and the Stigma of Vulnerability
Increased attention has been drawn to the critical issue of mental health among men worldwide. Societal expectations and stigma often discourage men from seeking help for mental health challenges, resulting in a significant number of untreated conditions. The male suicide rate in sub-Saharan Africa stands at 18 per 100,000, which is considerably higher than the global average of 12.4 per 100,000. The situation is equally concerning in South Africa, where men face disproportionately high rates of mental health difficulties and related deaths. These high prevalence rates are worsened by various factors, including poverty, the high prevalence of HIV/AIDS and limited access to mental health services for men.
This patriarchal framework often leads to mental health challenges among men being disregarded or trivialized, as societal expectations demand that men remain strong and dominant. Signs of vulnerability, such as expressing emotions or asking for help, are discouraged among males, which poses significant risks to their overall quality of life and mental wellbeing.
In masculine cultures, men who fail to meet societal and cultural expectations often face bashing, humiliation, ridicule and labels such as “weak”. This treatment is particularly evident among men who are perceived as “feminine” or overly connected to women. Consequently, they may endure social isolation, bullying, or even acts of violence. For those who strongly adhere to masculine ideology, failure to fulfil their “manly” responsibilities can result in feelings of emasculation. This inability to meet societal expectations often intensifies psychological suffering, leading to pronounced mental health challenges.
Read also: Traditional South African Bread
Men frequently associate masculinity with physical strength, which is linked to protecting the vulnerable and providing leadership. When they fail to fulfil these roles or suppress their vulnerabilities, it can lead to significant mental health consequences. For instance, men may avoid seeking psychological help because of the perception that only “weak” individuals pursue such assistance. An excessively rigid masculine identity can be detrimental to mental wellbeing, contributing to heightened anxiety, depression and feelings of loneliness. This pressure to conform often discourages men from seeking help for mental health issues, as doing so is seen as a sign of weakness.
Before addressing the interplay between masculinity and mental health, it is important to understand the general state of mental health in South Africa. Socioeconomic inequalities, historical trauma, sociopolitical history, and insufficient mental health services contribute to the prevalence of mental health disorders, making them a significant public health concern. Studies suggest that nearly one in three people in South Africa will face a mental health issue during their lifetime. Despite these troubling statistics, only 5% of the national health budget is allocated to mental health services, leaving them severely under-resourced.
The Need for Cultural Reform
South Africans are in need of a cultural reform. Mental health challenges have become a pressing public health concern in recent years, with the World Health Organization (WHO) reporting a notable prevalence of such difficulties in Africa. Within the region, the contributing factors to this conundrum include inadequate infrastructure, severe underfunding and a strong adherence to masculine culture.
We have been lucky up until this point. We have managed to sort of stagger along pretending that nothing needs to change and a working unified republic will one day just happen. But the cracks are beginning to show.
The end of Apartheid was, by comparison, tame. I do remember the 1995 Rugby World Cup Final - I watched Nelson Mandela and Francois Pienaar victoriously lift the William Webb Ellis trophy together live on national television - and it seemed then, that maybe, just maybe, everything was going to be ok.
But things are not ok. We live in a very hurt society. Some of this damage is historical, some of it is caused by our current government. Some of it is the fault of white people, some of it is the fault of black people. And through all of it, no one is willing to take responsibility, and no one is willing to change.
The rampant crime, corruption and social decay that plagues our nation is not happening in spite of the best wishes of the average South African. It’s happening because the average South African is happy to believe a lie. A simple lie, but pervasive. And the lie is this: It’s not your fault. You’re not to blame. The problem lies with someone else.
White people blame the corrupt government. Black people blame the historical injustices of the past. Zulu people blame immigrants from other African countries. The EFF blame the ANC, the ANC blame the DA. Eskom is at fault. The police force is at fault. The mines are at fault. The game farms are at fault. It’s always them. Never us.
If Spitting Image were to release their song today, they might need to add a few extra lines to the chorus, perhaps something about a small black political elite abusing the masses to build themselves a network of massive wealth. Maybe they would add something about Nkandla, and arms deals, and how disgusting the rape statistics are in black communities in South Africa. But they wouldn't have to take anything out of the song, and they certainly wouldn't have to change its title. In a country of 50 plus million people, it is still quite hard to find a nice South African.
