The story of the Israelites' sojourn in Egypt is a cornerstone of Jewish history and religious tradition. The biblical narrative, primarily found in the Book of Exodus, describes a period of migration, enslavement, and eventual liberation under the leadership of Moses. However, the historicity of the Exodus has been a subject of intense scholarly debate, with various theories and interpretations emerging over time.
"The Departure of the Israelites from Egypt" by David Roberts.
Biblical Account of the Israelites in Egypt
The Bible details Israel’s time in Egypt with remarkable clarity, specifying when the Semitic descendants of Abraham arrived, where they settled, their activities, interactions with Egyptians, the timing of their departure, and the dramatic events surrounding the Exodus.
According to Genesis 46:27, Jacob and his family numbered 70 people when they moved to Egypt. The book of Exodus describes their descent into slavery and miraculous rescue after some 430 years. Scripture indicates Israel grew rapidly during their time in Egypt (Exodus 1:7). That growth was fast enough to make Egyptian leaders nervous (Exodus 1:8-10).
Also, contrary to the notion that the Israelites were very downtrodden, other verses describe them as leaving Egypt with great wealth: God lends the people favor in Egyptian eyes, and the Egyptians give them gold and silver vessels (Exod. 11:2-3; 12:35-36). There is even a verse reading, “and the people of Israel went up armed out of the land of Egypt” (Exod. 13:18); literally, they were armed soldiers, the precise inversion of a downtrodden people. According to these verses, then, the exodus included a military element: armed Israelite soldiers and foreign mercenaries who came from abroad to help them.
Read also: Migration to Egypt
Alternative Perspectives and Theories
The story of the exodus from Egypt is very complex and may be taken two ways. On the one hand, it is the story of a group of miserable slaves coerced into forced building labor in Egypt. A charismatic leader called Moses emerges, and under his leadership the slaves manage to escape from Egypt: “And it was told to the king of Egypt that the people had fled” (Exod. 14:5). On the other hand, we are told that the Israelites are driven out of Egypt because of the Egyptians’ fear of them: “because they were driven out of Egypt” (Exod. 12:39).
Some scholars propose alternative interpretations of the Exodus narrative, drawing connections to Egyptian history and mythology. According to Manetho, a group called the Hyksos came from Canaan, overran Egypt, were driven out, went back to Canaan, and ultimately settled in Jerusalem. Later, the pharaoh named Amenophis, who wanted to come face to face with the gods, was told by his counselor that only if Egypt was cleansed of lepers would he be able to see the gods.
Amenophis collected all the lepers in Egypt together and settled them in a remote city, Avaris, which had previously been the Hyksos’s capital. The lepers rebelled against Amenophis and appointed a leper priest called Osarseph as their leader. Osarseph had previously served at the temple of the sun god (the biblical “On”) in Heliopolis, and he gave the lepers a new religion that was hostile to the Egyptian religion. When the lepers were attacked, Osarseph sent messengers abroad to conscript a militia. He approached the Hyksos in Jerusalem, and they arrived in thousands from Canaan to help Osarseph and the lepers, at which point Osarseph changed his name to Moses. Together, the lepers and the Jerusalemites formed a military power that took over Egypt, looted the Egyptian temples, profaned the idols, and slaughtered and ate the sacred animals. Amenophis fled Egypt and went to Ethiopia. Years later, Amenophis left Ethiopia with a huge army and returned to Egypt.
Römer concludes from these literary affinities that the writer of the exodus narrative borrowed these plotlines from Manetho. We have here a story of an ethnic group in Egypt that threatened the indigenous Egyptian religion and objected to the worship of Egyptian idols and sacred animals. And the children of Israel were fruitful and increased abundantly, and multiplied and grew exceedingly mighty; and the land was filled with them. . . . And he said to his people, Behold, the people of the children of Israel are more and mightier than we: come, let us deal wisely with them; lest they multiply and it come to pass that when any war should chance, they also join our enemies and fight against us and so go up out of the land (Exod.
Here, too, is a scenario whereby an enemy from within joins forces with an enemy from without.
Read also: History of Israelites
Dating the Exodus
I think one can point precisely to the time when these events took place, based both on the biblical story and the Manetho tradition. We have to go back to the story of the Egyptian prime minister Bay-Joseph and the child pharaoh Siptah, whom Bay puts on the throne. The widow queen Tausert, Seti II’s daughter by Merneptah’s widow, was active at that time. She ascended the throne after Seti’s death and became the sole ruler of Egypt. Her reign only lasted two or three years, (ca. 1190-1188 BCE), and then something mysterious happened, something wonderfully puzzling. This dynasty came to an end, and a new dynasty arose, the twentieth, established by Setnakhte, Ramses III’s father, who was later to fight the Philistines and other seafaring nations.
My claim is that the exodus from Egypt occurred in a specific year: 1186 BCE, which was the second year of Pharaoh Setnakhte’s reign. In summary, I believe the Israelites came to Egypt during the great famine, which began at the end of Ramses II’s reign, around 1225 BCE. They left at the beginning of Setnakhte’s reign, around 1186 BCE. This is a span of about 40 years.
Archaeological Evidence and Challenges
Although the biblical text clearly and explicitly documents Israel’s sojourn in Egypt, some scholars reject the idea that the Hebrews ever dwelt in Egypt. One primary reason they reject this biblical account as fiction is because of a purported lack of archaeological evidence.
Before we answer, it’s helpful to appreciate why evidence of Israel’s sojourn in Egypt can be hard to come by. First, many archaeologists simply cannot agree on when the Israelites were in Egypt. Second, only a tiny fraction of ancient Egypt has been excavated in controlled excavations. Third, slaves do not usually leave behind scads of evidence. Fourth, the ancient Egyptians are infamous for blotting out embarrassing historical events that would tarnish their reputation (which would certainly include the Exodus).
Despite these significant challenges, there is actually a reasonable amount of compelling evidence testifying to Israel’s time in Egypt.
Read also: Biblical Account of Captivity
- The Ibscha Relief: This tomb painting depicts a train of Asiatic (Semitic) men, women and children with goods, wearing unusual, bright, multicolored garments, arriving in Egypt from either Canaan or somewhere in the vicinity.
- The Famine Stele: This inscription recounts a story from Egypt’s distant past of a famine “in a period of seven years," which reads remarkably like the one in Genesis 41-47.
- Turin and Manetho King Lists: Rise of the Hyksos: The Turin King List records Egypt’s rulers during this crucial and fascinating period. The Hyksos were a group of immigrant Semitic rulers from the region of Canaan who rose to prominence in the northern Delta region of Egypt for a roughly 100-year period, around the 17th to 16th centuries b.c.e.
- Yaqub-har: One of these especially prominent Hyksos individuals is a man known from nearly 30 royal scarab seals found primarily throughout Canaan but also in Egypt. These scarabs, believed to date to the 17th century b.c.e., bear the name Yaqub-har. Yaqub is the exact transliteration of the Semitic name Jacob.
- Avaris: Classical historians record that the capital city of the Hyksos dynasty was called Avaris. Archaeologists have identified the ruins of Tell el-Dab’a in northern Egypt with ancient Avaris. Excavations at the site have revealed evidence of a clearly foreign, Semitic population, with housing styles similar to that of Canaan, along with Levantine-style weapons and pottery.
- The Carnarvon Tablet: The text reveals that Kamose feared the Hyksos were getting too powerful and needed to be overthrown. The text and geopolitical scene is uncannily reminiscent of Exodus 1:8-10.
- Rekhmire’s Tomb: On the walls of the Tomb of Rekhmire, painted images depict light-skinned Semitic slaves making bricks out of mud, water and chaff. The Bible also records the Hebrews making bricks in Egypt.
- Serabit el-Khadim: In 1905, Sir William F. Petrie discovered examples of early alphabetic script at Serabit el-Khadim. These “proto-Sinaitic” inscriptions, dating more specifically to the 16th-15th centuries b.c.e., are a precursor to the Hebrew alphabet (and other Levantine languages).
The following table summarizes the key points of evidence and their relation to the biblical narrative:
| Evidence | Description | Relevance to Biblical Narrative |
|---|---|---|
| Ibscha Relief | Depicts Semitic people entering Egypt | Supports the migration of Semites into Egypt during famine |
| Famine Stele | Describes a seven-year famine in Egypt | Corroborates the biblical account of famine during Joseph's time |
| Turin King List | Lists Hyksos rulers in Egypt | Provides historical context for Semitic rule in Egypt |
| Yaqub-har Scarabs | Seals bearing the name Yaqub (Jacob) | Suggests the presence of individuals with Hebrew names in Egypt |
| Avaris Excavations | Evidence of Semitic population and culture | Supports the existence of a Semitic community in Goshen |
| Carnarvon Tablet | Describes conflict with the Hyksos | Mirrors the biblical account of oppression of the Israelites |
| Rekhmire's Tomb | Depictions of Semitic slaves making bricks | Illustrates the enslavement of Hebrews in Egypt |
| Serabit el-Khadim | Proto-Sinaitic inscriptions | Demonstrates the development of early Hebrew script |
Population of Israelites during the Exodus
The number of Israelites who came up from Egypt and eventually entered the Promised Land is a matter of some debate. The two most common views on the population of the children of Israel are that they numbered over 2 million people or only about 30,000. That’s quite a difference.
Notably, no doctrinal or theological points rely on the precise population of Israel at the time of the exodus. Whether God freed 2 million or 30,000 from Egypt, Scripture is clear He did so miraculously (Exodus 6:6; Acts 7:35-36). Whether Israel’s fighting force was more than half a million or several thousand, their conquest of Canaan is credited entirely to God’s intervention (Deuteronomy 9:4-5).
As typically translated into English, the post-exodus Israelite army numbered well over 600,000 men. This figure implies a total Israelite population of about 2.4 million, a staggering figure for that era.
Trying to reconcile these points leads to several possibilities. As traditionally interpreted, the population of Israel would have been strikingly large for that era. That does not mean it is impossible. God’s miraculous provision could feed millions just as well as thousands. The idea of a people group growing from 70 to more than 2 million in 430 years is not implausible. It would require a population growth rate of 2.6 percent. This is extraordinarily high but not too far beyond the 2.2 percent growth rate seen worldwide in the middle of the twentieth century.
The common Hebrew term ‘elep is typically translated “thousand” (Exodus 18:21), such as in the first chapter of Numbers. The counts given in this chapter are composed of words, not numerals. However, two words in this phrase are subject to variations: ‘elep and vav. The term ‘elep (or ‘eleph) is used elsewhere in Scripture as a reference to groups, not a literal number, including descriptions of Israel during and after the exodus. Further, the connecting word vav can mean “and,” but it can also mean “or,” depending on context.
Scripture does not place any theological significance on the exact number of people who participated in the exodus. The intent of the Old Testament is to record the history of God’s intervention on Israel’s behalf and their response, good and bad. The fact that the Bible gives little space, other than a few verses, to the numbers of people implies that those numbers are not crucial in and of themselves.
Old Testament: Genesis and Exodus (Full Episode) | Buried Secrets of the Bible with Albert Lin
Popular articles:
tags: #Egypt
